PLEASE save this house!

This just breaks my heart. This is an INCREDIBLE house in Fleischmanns, NY. While the porch is in extreme condition, it is mostly intact and could be restored. It would be far far worse if the porch had been lost over the years.

While the porch is in extreme condition, the rest of the house appears to be in good shape. To me, the porch looks wholly restorable.

The house was designed by architect George F. Barber, who became nationally known by marketing his designs through a series of mail-order catalogs. The fabulous Old House Dreams blog has a whole list of mouth-watering Barber designs. The house above is design no. 37 from Barber’s “New Model Dwellings.”

There is a reprint of Barber’s work.

The small community has an astounding twelve Barber-designed homes, such as this knock-out. There may be more.

Another knock-out in the town, now a retreat.

While Fleischmanns is a small town, it is less than 3 hours from NYC. I can see somebody owning a small apartment in the city, and spending their weekends in this expansive, luscious house.
9 Comments
Leave a Reply Cancel Reply
Your email address will NEVER be made public or shared, and you may use a screen name if you wish.


Such a pitiful house, it breaks my heart anyone would allow demolition by neglect to happen to an old home like that.
Reminds me, this recent article on one of my favorite homes.
Well as far as I can see after several Google searches, the house is not for sale. At one point someone suggested knocking on the door or speaking to town officials. It’s sad but it may be in even worse shape now. The pics are from 2008 I think.
Is it for sale? How much is it?
I don’t know, Luke.
Zillow states that the house is not for sale. That does not mean though that it cannot be purchased.
Here are more recent, and horrifying, images.
So I zoomed in, for no apparent reason on the top windows (the three that are together).
Last one on right – out of the 3.
NO ONE else noticed the face that is staring back???? ZOINKS
Ps: I’d still love to own/fix this big beautiful bitch!!!
Is there a way to own this home? I am a disabled veteran, and would need help fixing it up. Could I get help for information on this Could be beautiful again, home.
I live in a old home that is very old and needs fix up bad I know it’s way over 100 years old we are older people I would love to know how to fix this home up thank you for the work you do
This house was owned by my Aunt Catherine Careccio in the 1960s. I think my grandmother (Aunt Catherine’s mother) owned it before her. The house was named Maria Cottage after my grandmother. Aunt Catherine, who lived in NYC, stayed at the house in the summer but rented rooms to folks who came to Fleischmanns in the summer.
My bother and I used to play in the adjacent apple grove and on the hill in front. Aunt Catherine gave us a sheet to make a tent out of in the grove. We also swam in the pool at the nearby hotel.
Maria Cottage had a number of rooms in it which Aunt Catherine rented. It had a lovely dining room and a kitchen warmed by a cast iron stove.